Minwax vs Varathane stain

Minwax vs Varathane is the most common stain question at the hardware store, because the two cans sit side by side, cost about the same and both claim to be oil-based penetrating stains. The real differences are dry time, color range and how each one handles a second coat.

Minwax Wood Finish is the slower, traditional stain with the bigger list of classic browns. Varathane Premium Fast Dry is built for speed and carries more grays, blues and modern tones. Below you will find both color charts and the nearest Varathane color for every Minwax shade.

50 colors listed. Tap one for the species notes and the closest match in other brands.

Color chart at a glance

ColorCodeDepthUndertone
Varathane Aged Barrel - Dark deep warm barrel-brown
Varathane Aged Wheat - Light light warm wheat-tan
Varathane Barn Red - Medium-dark saturated barn-red
Varathane Black Cherry - Dark deep near-black red-brown
Varathane Bleached Blue - Medium pale washed blue-gray
Varathane Briarsmoke - Medium-dark smoky warm gray-brown
Varathane Cabernet - Dark deep wine-red brown
Varathane Carbon Gray - Medium-dark deep charcoal-gray
Minwax Cherry 235 Medium-dark warm reddish-orange brown
Minwax Classic Gray 271 Medium true medium gray, minimal brown cast
Minwax Colonial Maple 223 Medium warm golden tan, light depth
Minwax Dark Walnut 2716 Dark deep cool-neutral brown
Minwax Driftwood 2126 Light pale warm gray, a bleached-driftwood look
Minwax Early American 230 Medium-dark warm reddish-brown, one of the most popular Minwax colors
Minwax Ebony 2718 Dark near-black, faint warm cast
Minwax English Chestnut 233 Dark warm reddish medium-dark brown
Minwax Espresso 273 Dark very dark neutral-cool brown, a hair deeper than Jacobean
Varathane Fogstone - Light pale cool stone-gray
Minwax Fruitwood 241 Medium warm light-medium tan-brown
Minwax Golden Oak 210B Medium warm honey-gold, classic oak-cabinet tone
Minwax Golden Pecan 245 Medium warm medium gold-brown
Minwax Gunstock 231 Medium warm medium brown, a step darker than Golden Oak
Minwax Ipswich Pine 221 Medium warm amber-tan, deeper than Puritan Pine
Minwax Jacobean 2750 Dark very dark cool-neutral brown, nearly black
Varathane Light Walnut - Medium warm medium tan-brown
Varathane Midnight Blue - Dark near-black navy
Minwax Natural 209 Light near-clear warm amber, barely darkens the wood
Minwax Navy 286 Dark deep muted navy-gray
Minwax Nutmeg - Medium-dark warm medium-dark brown
Minwax Phantom Gray 1089 Medium-dark deep cool charcoal-gray
Minwax Pickled Oak 260 Light whitewash gray-white, a limed-oak look
Minwax Provincial 211 Medium-dark grayish medium-dark brown, muted rather than warm
Minwax Puritan Pine 218 Light warm tan-gold, light-to-medium depth
Minwax Red Chestnut 232 Medium-dark warm reddish-brown, between English Chestnut and Sedona Red
Minwax Red Mahogany 225 Dark deep warm red-brown
Minwax Red Oak 215 Medium warm reddish-tan, medium depth
Varathane Rustic Sage - Medium muted sage-green
Minwax Sedona Red 222 Medium-dark warm terracotta-red
Minwax Simply White 275 Light a whitewash rather than a true white, grain still shows through
Minwax Special Walnut 224 Medium-dark warm medium-dark brown, balances gold and walnut
Varathane Traditional Cherry - Medium-dark warm reddish-brown
Minwax True Black 274 Dark true neutral black, no undertone
Varathane True Brown - Dark neutral medium-dark brown
Varathane Vintage Aqua - Medium muted teal-aqua
Minwax Vintage Blue 288 Medium muted slate blue-gray
Varathane Vintage Denim - Medium-dark muted denim-blue
Varathane Weathered Gray - Medium medium weathered gray
Minwax Weathered Oak 270 Medium light gray-brown, a weathered-wood look
Varathane Willow Gray - Medium soft neutral gray
Varathane Worn Navy - Dark deep worn navy

Closest Varathane match for each color

Closeness is the perceptual color distance between the two published swatches. On real wood both stains shift with species and the number of coats, so treat a near match as a starting point and confirm it on a scrap of your own board.

Dry time and working time

The biggest practical difference is speed. Varathane Premium Fast Dry is designed to be ready for a second coat or a topcoat in about an hour in normal conditions. Minwax Wood Finish needs several hours before a second coat and longer before a topcoat. If you want to stain and seal a piece in one afternoon, Varathane is the easier fit.

Speed cuts the other way on big surfaces. A fast-drying stain gives you less time to wipe off the excess, so on a large tabletop or a door you can get lap marks where one pass dries before the next overlaps it. Minwax stays workable longer, which is more forgiving for beginners and large panels. Work in smaller sections with Varathane.

Color range

Minwax has the deeper list of traditional wood tones: Special Walnut, Early American, Provincial, Dark Walnut, Jacobean, Golden Oak and the reds. Many furniture refinishing tutorials and older kitchens are specified in Minwax colors, so if you are matching existing trim, Minwax often has the exact name.

Varathane is stronger on grays, weathered looks and muted colors such as Weathered Gray, Carbon Gray, Fogstone, Vintage Denim and Rustic Sage. If you want a modern gray or a soft blue on furniture, Varathane has more options. The match table on this page shows where the two ranges overlap closely and where a Minwax color has no real Varathane twin.

How each one looks on wood

Both are penetrating stains, so both blotch on pine, maple and birch without a pre-stain conditioner, and both make open-grained oak look striking. In practice Varathane tends to deliver more color in a single coat, while Minwax builds up more gradually, which makes it easier to stop at exactly the depth you want with a second coat.

Neither is a finish. Both need a topcoat such as polyurethane for any surface that will be handled or wiped. Use a topcoat that is compatible with an oil-based stain and let the stain dry fully first, especially with Minwax, or the topcoat can lift color.

Which one to buy

Pick Minwax when you are matching an existing Minwax color, working on a large piece where open time matters, or want the classic browns. Pick Varathane when speed matters, when you want a gray, blue or other modern tone, or when you want strong color from one coat on a small project. For either brand, stain a scrap of the same wood first, because the swatch on the can is printed on a reference wood that may not be yours.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Minwax or Varathane wood stain better?

Varathane is superior for fast project completion due to its 1-hour dry time and rich one-coat pigment saturation. Minwax offers a longer working time with less risk of lap marks on large surfaces, along with classical traditional brown tones.

Can you mix Minwax and Varathane oil stains together?

Yes, as long as both products are traditional penetrating oil formulations, they can be blended to achieve custom intermediate tones. Do not mix oil-based stains with water-based stains.

Does Varathane stain darker than Minwax in one coat?

Yes. In side-by-side shop tests, Varathane Premium Fast Dry utilizes fine nano-pigments that yield a richer, darker color in a single coat compared to Minwax Wood Finish, which often requires two coats for full depth.

More stain color guides