Best stain colors for pine

Pine has soft, uneven density, so a thin oil stain soaks in unevenly and blotches. Use a pre-stain wood conditioner first, or pick a gel stain, which sits on the surface.

The colors below are the ones this site tags as good on pine, plus every gel stain.

26 colors listed. Tap one for the species notes and the closest match in other brands.

Color chart at a glance

ColorCodeDepthUndertone
Varathane Aged Wheat - Light light warm wheat-tan
General Finishes American Oak - Medium warm medium oak-gold
General Finishes Antique Walnut - Medium-dark warm medium-dark walnut
General Finishes Ash Gray - Medium neutral warm-gray
General Finishes Black - Dark true opaque black
General Finishes Brown Mahogany - Dark deep warm reddish-brown
General Finishes Candlelite - Light warm golden honey
General Finishes Carbon Gray - Medium-dark deep charcoal-gray
Minwax Cherry 235 Medium-dark warm reddish-orange brown
General Finishes Colonial Maple - Medium warm golden tan
Minwax Early American 230 Medium-dark warm reddish-brown, one of the most popular Minwax colors
Minwax Fruitwood 241 Medium warm light-medium tan-brown
General Finishes Georgian Cherry - Medium-dark warm reddish cherry-brown
General Finishes Gray - Medium true medium gray
Minwax Ipswich Pine 221 Medium warm amber-tan, deeper than Puritan Pine
General Finishes Java - Dark deep near-black coffee-brown
General Finishes New Pine - Light light warm pine-tan
Minwax Nutmeg - Medium-dark warm medium-dark brown
General Finishes Nutmeg - Medium-dark warm medium-dark brown
General Finishes Prairie Wheat - Light warm wheat-tan
Minwax Puritan Pine 218 Light warm tan-gold, light-to-medium depth
Minwax Red Chestnut 232 Medium-dark warm reddish-brown, between English Chestnut and Sedona Red
Minwax Sedona Red 222 Medium-dark warm terracotta-red
Minwax Special Walnut 224 Medium-dark warm medium-dark brown, balances gold and walnut
Varathane Traditional Cherry - Medium-dark warm reddish-brown
General Finishes White - Light opaque warm white, hides grain more than a whitewash

Frequently Asked Questions

What stain color looks best on pine?

Medium golden and warm brown stains look best on pine, such as Minwax Early American, Special Walnut, and Varathane Golden Pecan. These shades harmonize with pine's natural yellow-amber undertones without turning orange or muddy.

How do you keep pine from blotching when staining?

Apply a generous coat of pre-stain wood conditioner and let it soak in for 10 to 15 minutes before wiping off the excess. Apply your oil-based stain within 2 hours. Alternatively, use a gel stain, which sits on the surface rather than penetrating erratically.

Can you stain pine without wood conditioner?

Staining pine with penetrating oil stain without conditioner usually causes severe blotchiness, especially around soft earlywood grain and knots. If you skip conditioner, choose a heavy-bodied gel stain or dewaxed shellac washcoat instead.

Does dark stain look good on pine?

Dark stains such as Dark Walnut, Jacobean, or Ebony can look striking on pine, but they require meticulous sanding up to 180-grit, a pre-stain conditioner, and ideally a gel stain formulation to prevent patchy, muddy absorption.

More stain color guides