Traditional Mahogany vs Cheyenne Red

Both Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck solid stains sit in the red family, but Traditional Mahogany is a deeper, more brown-leaning red, while Cheyenne Red is more saturated and closer to true red.

Traditional Mahogany Sherwin-Williams · SuperDeck Solid SW 3080
Sold at Sherwin-Williams stores, not on Amazon.

Pick Traditional Mahogany for a deck or railing that wants a rich red-brown without reading as bright red.

Cheyenne Red Sherwin-Williams · SuperDeck Solid SW 3043
Sold at Sherwin-Williams stores, not on Amazon.

Pick Cheyenne Red for a barn-red look on fences, sheds or siding.

How close are they?

Delta-E (perceptual color distance) between Traditional Mahogany and Cheyenne Red is 14.4 (a clearly distinguishable difference once you see them next to each other).

Side by side

Traditional MahoganyCheyenne Red
Brand and line Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck Solid Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck Solid
Color code SW 3080 SW 3043
Stain type exterior-solid exterior-solid
Hex (approx.) #5A2E24 #7A3428
Lightness (L*) 24 31
Undertone deep warm mahogany-red saturated brick-red

Cheyenne Red is the lighter of the two by about 7 points of lightness on a 0 to 100 scale, so Traditional Mahogany will hide more of the wood's own grain and color on the same board. Hex values are on-screen approximations of each published swatch; confirm on a test board of your own wood before committing.

How each behaves on pressure-treated pine, cedar, redwood and weathered wood

Pressure-treated pine

Traditional Mahogany: Traditional Mahogany fully hides pressure-treated pine's green tint and knots, so the deck ends up close to the color chip. It needs dry, clean wood to bond: on new lumber, wait until sprinkled water soaks in instead of beading.

Cheyenne Red: Cheyenne Red fully hides pressure-treated pine's green tint and knots, so the deck ends up close to the color chip. It needs dry, clean wood to bond: on new lumber, wait until sprinkled water soaks in instead of beading.

Cedar

Traditional Mahogany: On cedar, Traditional Mahogany covers both the grain and the wood's own color. Cedar's tannins can bleed through lighter solid colors as tan or brown blotches, so a darker color or a stain-blocking primer avoids that.

Cheyenne Red: On cedar, Cheyenne Red covers both the grain and the wood's own color. Cedar's tannins can bleed through lighter solid colors as tan or brown blotches, so a darker color or a stain-blocking primer avoids that.

Redwood

Traditional Mahogany: Redwood carries even more tannin than cedar, so the main risk with Traditional Mahogany is bleed-through on light colors in the first weeks. Deep browns and reds hide it; with a light color, prime first.

Cheyenne Red: Redwood carries even more tannin than cedar, so the main risk with Cheyenne Red is bleed-through on light colors in the first weeks. Deep browns and reds hide it; with a light color, prime first.

Weathered gray wood

Traditional Mahogany: This is where a solid stain like Traditional Mahogany earns its place: it covers gray, mismatched and patched boards in one even color, as long as loose gray fibers are scrubbed off first so the coating has sound wood to grip.

Cheyenne Red: This is where a solid stain like Cheyenne Red earns its place: it covers gray, mismatched and patched boards in one even color, as long as loose gray fibers are scrubbed off first so the coating has sound wood to grip.