Traditional Mahogany vs Cheyenne Red
Both Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck solid stains sit in the red family, but Traditional Mahogany is a deeper, more brown-leaning red, while Cheyenne Red is more saturated and closer to true red.
Pick Traditional Mahogany for a deck or railing that wants a rich red-brown without reading as bright red.
Pick Cheyenne Red for a barn-red look on fences, sheds or siding.
How close are they?
Delta-E (perceptual color distance) between Traditional Mahogany and Cheyenne Red is 14.4 (a clearly distinguishable difference once you see them next to each other).
Side by side
| Traditional Mahogany | Cheyenne Red | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand and line | Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck Solid | Sherwin-Williams SuperDeck Solid |
| Color code | SW 3080 | SW 3043 |
| Stain type | exterior-solid | exterior-solid |
| Hex (approx.) | #5A2E24 | #7A3428 |
| Lightness (L*) | 24 | 31 |
| Undertone | deep warm mahogany-red | saturated brick-red |
Cheyenne Red is the lighter of the two by about 7 points of lightness on a 0 to 100 scale, so Traditional Mahogany will hide more of the wood's own grain and color on the same board. Hex values are on-screen approximations of each published swatch; confirm on a test board of your own wood before committing.
How each behaves on pressure-treated pine, cedar, redwood and weathered wood
Pressure-treated pine
Traditional Mahogany: Traditional Mahogany fully hides pressure-treated pine's green tint and knots, so the deck ends up close to the color chip. It needs dry, clean wood to bond: on new lumber, wait until sprinkled water soaks in instead of beading.
Cheyenne Red: Cheyenne Red fully hides pressure-treated pine's green tint and knots, so the deck ends up close to the color chip. It needs dry, clean wood to bond: on new lumber, wait until sprinkled water soaks in instead of beading.
Cedar
Traditional Mahogany: On cedar, Traditional Mahogany covers both the grain and the wood's own color. Cedar's tannins can bleed through lighter solid colors as tan or brown blotches, so a darker color or a stain-blocking primer avoids that.
Cheyenne Red: On cedar, Cheyenne Red covers both the grain and the wood's own color. Cedar's tannins can bleed through lighter solid colors as tan or brown blotches, so a darker color or a stain-blocking primer avoids that.
Redwood
Traditional Mahogany: Redwood carries even more tannin than cedar, so the main risk with Traditional Mahogany is bleed-through on light colors in the first weeks. Deep browns and reds hide it; with a light color, prime first.
Cheyenne Red: Redwood carries even more tannin than cedar, so the main risk with Cheyenne Red is bleed-through on light colors in the first weeks. Deep browns and reds hide it; with a light color, prime first.
Weathered gray wood
Traditional Mahogany: This is where a solid stain like Traditional Mahogany earns its place: it covers gray, mismatched and patched boards in one even color, as long as loose gray fibers are scrubbed off first so the coating has sound wood to grip.
Cheyenne Red: This is where a solid stain like Cheyenne Red earns its place: it covers gray, mismatched and patched boards in one even color, as long as loose gray fibers are scrubbed off first so the coating has sound wood to grip.