Early American vs Dark Walnut

Early American is a medium warm reddish-brown; Dark Walnut is far darker and cooler. Both are common floor stains, but they produce very different rooms.

Early American Minwax · Wood Finish 230

Pick Early American for a warm, traditional floor or furniture color that still shows the grain clearly.

Dark Walnut Minwax · Wood Finish 2716

Pick Dark Walnut for a darker, cooler, more modern floor or cabinet that hides grain and color variation.

How close are they?

Delta-E (perceptual color distance) between Early American and Dark Walnut is 22.7 (a clearly distinguishable difference once you see them next to each other).

Side by side

Early AmericanDark Walnut
Brand and line Minwax Wood Finish Minwax Wood Finish
Color code 230 2716
Stain type oil oil
Hex (approx.) #7B4A34 #402A20
Lightness (L*) 37 19
Undertone warm reddish-brown, one of the most popular Minwax colors deep cool-neutral brown

Early American is the lighter of the two by about 17 points of lightness on a 0 to 100 scale, so Dark Walnut will hide more of the wood's own grain and color on the same board. Hex values are on-screen approximations of each published swatch; confirm on a test board of your own wood before committing.

How each behaves on pine, oak, maple and cabinets

Pine

Early American: Pine's grain runs soft and uneven in density, so Early American (a thin, deep-penetrating oil stain) is prone to blotching here unless the wood gets a pre-stain conditioner first.

Dark Walnut: Pine's grain runs soft and uneven in density, so Dark Walnut (a thin, deep-penetrating oil stain) is prone to blotching here unless the wood gets a pre-stain conditioner first.

Oak

Early American: Oak's large, open pores soak up an oil stain like Early American unevenly in a good way: it settles into the grain and makes the natural texture pop rather than looking flat.

Dark Walnut: Oak's large, open pores soak up an oil stain like Dark Walnut unevenly in a good way: it settles into the grain and makes the natural texture pop rather than looking flat.

Maple

Early American: Maple is dense and tight-grained with almost no texture to hide unevenness, so Early American blotches badly here without a conditioner or a test board first. This is the wood oil stains struggle with most.

Dark Walnut: Maple is dense and tight-grained with almost no texture to hide unevenness, so Dark Walnut blotches badly here without a conditioner or a test board first. This is the wood oil stains struggle with most.

Cabinets

Early American: On cabinet doors, an oil stain like Early American can lap-mark where one panel overlaps the next during application; wipe fast and work one door at a time to keep the color even.

Dark Walnut: On cabinet doors, an oil stain like Dark Walnut can lap-mark where one panel overlaps the next during application; wipe fast and work one door at a time to keep the color even.