Cedar vs Russet

Both are Behr semi-transparent exterior stains, but they are far apart: Cedar (ST-146) is a medium golden-brown, while Russet (ST-117) is a dark red-brown that reads much deeper on the same boards.

Cedar Behr · Premium Semi-Transparent ST-146
Sold at The Home Depot, not on Amazon.

Pick Cedar for new or lightly weathered decking that should look like natural, golden wood.

Russet Behr · Premium Semi-Transparent ST-117
Sold at The Home Depot, not on Amazon.

Pick Russet for a rich, dark red-brown deck, or for older boards where a deeper color hides more variation.

How close are they?

Delta-E (perceptual color distance) between Cedar and Russet is 36.2 (a clearly distinguishable difference once you see them next to each other).

Side by side

CedarRusset
Brand and line Behr Premium Semi-Transparent Behr Premium Semi-Transparent
Color code ST-146 ST-117
Stain type exterior-semi-transparent exterior-semi-transparent
Hex (approx.) #9B6E3C #48291D
Lightness (L*) 50 20
Undertone medium golden-brown dark red-brown

Cedar is the lighter of the two by about 30 points of lightness on a 0 to 100 scale, so Russet will hide more of the wood's own grain and color on the same board. Hex values are on-screen approximations of each published swatch; confirm on a test board of your own wood before committing.

How each behaves on pressure-treated pine, cedar, redwood and weathered wood

Pressure-treated pine

Cedar: New pressure-treated pine has a green or yellow cast, and Cedar is translucent, so that tint shows through: expect it to look lighter and more golden than the swatch for the first season. Let new boards dry until water soaks in before staining.

Russet: New pressure-treated pine has a green or yellow cast, and Russet is translucent, so that tint shows through: expect it to look lighter and more golden than the swatch for the first season. Let new boards dry until water soaks in before staining.

Cedar

Cedar: On cedar, Cedar sits over the wood's own reddish-tan tone, so it reads warmer and a little deeper than on pine. New cedar is often smooth and oily; a deck cleaner or brightener first helps the stain soak in evenly.

Russet: On cedar, Russet sits over the wood's own reddish-tan tone, so it reads warmer and a little deeper than on pine. New cedar is often smooth and oily; a deck cleaner or brightener first helps the stain soak in evenly.

Redwood

Cedar: Redwood is the darkest and reddest of the common decking woods, so Cedar looks deepest here, and the lighter colors barely change it. On redwood it enriches the existing color more than it replaces it.

Russet: Redwood is the darkest and reddest of the common decking woods, so Russet looks deepest here, and the lighter colors barely change it. On redwood it enriches the existing color more than it replaces it.

Weathered gray wood

Cedar: A semi-transparent stain like Cedar does not hide gray weathering: whatever gray is left after cleaning shows through and muddies the color. Clean and brighten old boards first, or switch to a solid color if the gray will not come out.

Russet: A semi-transparent stain like Russet does not hide gray weathering: whatever gray is left after cleaning shows through and muddies the color. Clean and brighten old boards first, or switch to a solid color if the gray will not come out.